Apple TV+’s “The Big Cigar” lights up the screen with a daring blend of historical drama and fictionalized flair, diving into the extraordinary escape of Black Panther Party co-founder Huey P. Newton to Cuba. But don’t expect a dry retelling of events – this series boldly acknowledges its Hollywood lens, promising a unique perspective on radical politics.
The Big Cigar
On one hand, André Holland’s performance as Newton is consistently lauded as the highlight of the show. He embodies the charisma and complexity of the revolutionary leader, capturing his quiet intensity and unwavering commitment to his cause. Holland’s portrayal is described as “subtle,” “very good,” and even “Emmy-worthy” by some reviewers.
The show’s 70s aesthetic, with its grainy film look and split-screen montages, is stylish and authentic. Don Cheadle, who directs the first two episodes, sets the tone for a visually engaging series. The dialogue,too, is commended for its intelligence and thought-provoking nature.
However, “The Big Cigar” struggles to maintain a consistent tone and narrative focus. The series attempts to juggle multiple storylines, jumping back and forth in time, which leaves some critics feeling disoriented and overwhelmed. The result, a feeling that this is more like two different shows put together.
The show’s uneven tone is also a point of contention. While the scenes with the Black Panthers are treated with sincerity and respect, the portrayal of the Hollywood figures who aided Newton’s escape to Cuba often veers into satire. This tonal dissonance detracts from the show’s overall impact and leaves some viewers feeling emotionally disconnected.
Furthermore, while the show touches upon important themes of racial injustice and political activism, it fails to delve deeper into the nuances of Newton’s life and the broader context of the Black Panther movement. Another criticism, is its length. The story could have been told more effectively as a concise film rather than a drawn-out miniseries. The pacing feels uneven, with some episodes dragging while others rush through crucial plot points.
In conclusion, “The Big Cigar” is a bit flawed but intriguing series that sparks curiosity about a pivotal figure in American history. While it may not be a definitive portrayal of Huey P. Newton, it serves as a starting point for further exploration and discussion. If you’re looking for a stylish and entertaining series with a strong lead performance, “The Big Cigar” might be worth a watch. But if you’re seeking a comprehensive and nuanced historical drama, you may be left wanting more.
