Grand Theft Auto VI hasn’t launched yet, but it already sits at the top of Metacritic’s all-time rankings. Rockstar’s long-awaited sequel holds a score of 99, which moves it above The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Nintendo’s 1998 classic had long been treated as the benchmark for critically acclaimed games.
The timing is notable. The game releases on November 19, ending a 13-year wait since Grand Theft Auto V. Fans who have spent more than a decade on trailers, leaks and delays are now about to find out whether the reviews match what they experience on their own consoles.
The high score itself is not very surprising, because Rockstar’s track record on Metacritic is hard to match. Four Grand Theft Auto games already appear in the site’s top 20, and Red Dead Redemption 2 ranks 11th. Few studios have placed so many games that high, so critics were expected to rate GTA VI well. The size of the score is still striking.
Reviewers mostly praise the same things. The open world is described as dense and detailed enough to keep players busy long after the main missions are done, and the systems leave room for experimentation. IGN’s reviewer called it the single most impressive game he has ever played. Other critics praised the story, the cast and the mission design. The fictional state of Leonida is widely described as a worthy successor to Los Santos.
Some caution is reasonable. Early aggregate scores often drop slightly as more reviews arrive, and big releases can reveal performance problems or design frustrations that pre-release review sessions didn’t expose. Ocarina of Time also earned its score from a much smaller pool of critics, in a very different era of games criticism. Comparing the two says as much about how review culture has changed as it does about either game.
Hardware is another issue. Ahead of launch, the PlayStation 5 Pro is reported to be the only console that offers ray-traced shadows, and the console’s price has risen sharply. That gives players a hard decision about whether a visual upgrade is worth paying a premium. Reviews suggest the game holds up on standard hardware too, so it’s unclear how many buyers will feel they need the upgrade.
The more important test comes after launch, once millions of players start exploring Leonida. A 99 score shows that critics are impressed. Whether GTA VI lasts as long in players’ minds as Ocarina of Time has will depend on how it is remembered years from now.
